Beyond Pumpkin Spice: 3 Fall Coffees to Try This Season

As soon as September hits, everyone starts talking about pumpkin spice.

And while we’re definitely not complaining about pumpkin season, pumpkin spice coffee isn’t the only way to get a little fall flavor in your mug.

Here are three fall favorites to try when you’re ready to switch things up:

1. Apple Cookie Butter

If fall had a smell, it might be baked apples and cinnamon.

Our Apple Cookie Butter Coffee brings together baked apple, creamy cookie butter, cinnamon and brown sugar for a cup that tastes like it belongs next to a plate of something freshly baked.

It’s sweet, warm and definitely gives off “I should probably be eating an apple dessert right now” energy.

Try this one if: you’re an apple-picking, cinnamon-loving, bakery-dessert kind of person.

Shop this coffee • Apple Cookie Butter

2. Pumpkin Crème Brûlée

Pumpkin spice gets all the attention, but Pumpkin Crème Brûlée Coffee is here to remind you that pumpkin can do more than cinnamon and nutmeg.

This one leans into the dessert side of fall with pumpkin, creamy vanilla custard and caramelized sugar flavors.

Think pumpkin dessert, but in your coffee mug.

Try this one if: your ideal fall afternoon involves a blanket, a dessert menu and absolutely no one asking you to share.

Shop this coffee • Pumpkin Crème Brûlée

3. Subcutaneous S’mores™

Okay, technically s’mores aren't exclusive to fall.

But when the weather starts cooling down and you start thinking about campfires, this one just makes sense.

Our Subcutaneous S’mores™ Coffee combines milk chocolate, toasted marshmallow and sweet graham cracker flavors for a coffee inspired by the classic campfire treat.

And there’s a pretty interesting story behind the name, too. Mike Adams (founder of Firehouse Coffee) states, “S’mores have always been one of my favorite campfire treats because every bite is made up of delicious layers. As a firefighter and MedEvac Flight Paramedic, those layers reminded me of the layers of skin we studied throughout our medical training, including the subcutaneous layer.” The bag artwork was created by Mike’s daughter, Lily, and the coffee is dedicated to burn-unit professionals.

Try this one if: you want your coffee to taste like s’mores without having to build a campfire first.

Shop this coffee • Subcutaneous S’mores™

But What About Pumpkin Spice?

Don’t worry. We didn’t forget about it!

Our Pumpkin-itis™ Pumpkin Spice Coffee is still a fall classic for a reason. Cinnamon, nutmeg and clove give it those familiar warm pumpkin spice flavors that practically announce that fall has arrived.

So if you're the person who starts counting down to pumpkin season in July… we see you.

But if you’ve already had your fill of pumpkin spice, there are plenty of other flavored coffee options to try.

Your Fall Coffee Lineup Doesn't Have to Be Pumpkin

That’s really the point.

Fall coffee can mean pumpkin spice, but it can also mean baked apple, cookie butter, caramelized sugar, chocolate, toasted marshmallow and graham crackers.

And if you’re shopping for freshly roasted flavored coffee in Pennsylvania, you don’t have to look very far.

Firehouse Coffee roasts and flavors coffee right here in Maxatawny, PA, with more than 40 unique flavored coffees to choose from throughout the year.

So grab your favorite mug, pick a flavor and make yourself a cup of fall.

Or, you know… try all three. We won’t judge! 

Ready to find your next fall coffee?

Shop Firehouse Coffee in-store or online and explore our selection of freshly roasted flavored coffee, pumpkin coffee and seasonal favorites.