Bring home a treasured Pennsylvania Dutch tradition with Shoofly Pie Decaf Flavored Coffee K-Cups® from Firehouse Coffee. Inspired by the beloved homemade dessert, this gourmet decaf coffee captures the rich flavors of sweet molasses, brown sugar, warm cinnamon, and buttery pie crust in every smooth, satisfying cup.

The name Shoofly Pie has been part of Pennsylvania Dutch heritage for generations. As Mennonite women baked fresh pies, the sweet aroma attracted flies that had to be gently "shooed" away from the cooling pies. That simple tradition inspired one of Pennsylvania's most iconic desserts—and now one of Firehouse Coffee's most unique flavored coffees.

Founded by a retired firefighter and MedEvac Flight Paramedic, Firehouse Coffee roasts premium Swiss Water® Process decaffeinated 100% Arabica coffee in small batches before carefully adding our signature dessert-inspired flavors. The result is a rich, full-bodied decaf coffee with exceptional aroma and smooth flavor, without the caffeine.

Designed for Keurig®-compatible brewers, these convenient single-serve coffee pods make it easy to enjoy a fresh cup in minutes. Whether you're relaxing after dinner, starting your morning with a taste of home, or searching for the best decaf flavored coffee K-Cups®, Pennsylvania Dutch coffee, gourmet dessert coffee, or Swiss Water® decaf coffee pods, Shoofly Pie delivers homemade flavor and small-batch quality in every brew.

Every box is proudly roasted and packaged in Pennsylvania by Firehouse Coffee, where tradition, craftsmanship, and premium coffee come together one cup at a time.

Why You'll Love It

• Swiss Water® Process decaffeinated coffee
• Fresh roasted in small batches
• Premium 100% Arabica coffee beans
• Rich molasses, brown sugar, cinnamon, and buttery pie crust flavors
• Compatible with Keurig®-style single-serve brewers
• Smooth, full-bodied gourmet flavor
• Firefighter-owned and operated
• Proudly roasted in Pennsylvania