Living in Pennsylvania Dutch country, horse and buggies are simply part of everyday life.

At Firehouse Coffee, it's not unusual to see Mennonite families pull into our roastery, tie their horses out back, and stop inside for fresh coffee. It's one of the things that makes our community unique, and over the years we've come to appreciate many of the traditions that have been passed down through generations.

One of those traditions is the famous Shoofly Pie.

Made with rich molasses and a tender breakfast-style cake filling, Shoofly Pie has been a Pennsylvania Dutch favorite for generations. Legend has it that fresh pies were often placed outside on cooling racks, where their sweet aroma attracted hungry flies. The bakers would wave their hands to "shoo" the flies away, giving the dessert its unforgettable name.

We wanted to capture that hometown favorite in a cup.

ShooFly Pie™ Flavored Coffee blends the warm, comforting taste of rich molasses with sweet breakfast cake flavors to recreate one of Pennsylvania's most beloved desserts. Roasted in small batches using premium specialty-grade Arabica coffee beans, every cup delivers a smooth body, incredible aroma, and just the right touch of old-fashioned sweetness.

Founded by a retired firefighter and MedEvac Flight Paramedic, Firehouse Coffee proudly roasts every batch with the same care and attention that has made our coffee a favorite among first responders, healthcare professionals, and coffee lovers alike. ShooFly Pie™ is our tribute to the hardworking Mennonite families and the Pennsylvania Dutch traditions that make our hometown so special.

If you're searching for the best Shoofly Pie coffee, Pennsylvania Dutch coffee, molasses flavored coffee, dessert flavored coffee, small-batch roasted coffee, or gourmet flavored coffee, ShooFly Pie™ delivers a rich, comforting taste that's as timeless as the recipe that inspired it.